Joined: 05 Jan 2005 Location: off the grid, but still fighting for the users!
Posted: Mon Jun 01, 2009 10:35 am Post subject:
Ummm... well yours is ok I guess. I mean it's pretty well realised and looks and sounds ok but you made one big fuckup in having the gun that takes the chainsaw's place have infinite ammo. Oh and I didn't like the way your grenades just drop like lead weights - where is the bounce?! And why didn't you replace the pickup sprites?
Perhaps it is superior to cswp as it does have one more gun which means it's better suited to run on other WADs as it replaces all the Doom2 weapons. But they set out to do something different there - make much better looking and realistically animating guns. I don't think they had any frames left for the BFG
And their's isn't 'glitchy', it's just not meant to be used for games with monsters in.
As for using yours with Fistful... well what's wrong with sticking with the guns and sounds that Fistful has?
Furthermore then I couldn't even get your mod to run locally on top of (or below) Fistful
I don't feel like posting between your kinda argue (dunno if it has ended already) or something, but I'll..
First of all - my most favourite weapon - standart shotty (pump action). It feels like it has no recoil at all + no fire at end of barrel (I know this doesn't happen in real life, but original Doom weapons and most mods have it, and if so, why m4a1 deserves so damn huge "fire"?).. It feels wierd when you hold shooting button (it seems that it doesn't go back in ready mode)..
M4A1 - Too small (btw, isn't it shooting faster than Doomer's version of M4A1? I like that)
Desert eagle - this is pretty ok, but why the fuck does it have to move (bob) when you stand on the ground? Shooting sequence is good
Knife - same problem as desert + makes wierd sound when slices
AK47 (chainsaw replacement) - This is something that Doomer's CS weapons didn't have this, not bad (it's bit slower than m4a1 (I thought it's almostly identical speed at CS)
SMG - Ok, auto shotty would been more appealing to me
Grenade - explosion is delayed + why it doesn't bounce at all? It just does that wierd drop thing, Doomer's CS weps has alot better grenades.. Btw, you can kinda rocket (grenade) jump with them..
Sorta minigun - was that even in CS? Dunno, since I've plaid only 1.6.. Btw, why one shot is eqal to shotty's horizontal spray? Feels like rapid shotty..
AWP - Bfg cells? Anyawy, comparing to Doomer's CS weps (dunno how to short it), it's much more rapid, so by tapping shoot button, you can spam with it, and knowing 1 hit = 1 kill, it feels bit lame..
Overal : This is ok and playable wad, I would strongly recommend Doomer's version (since it's far more superior than this one) for DM kinda games, but since this seemly doesn't use monster sprites, this one's good for coop..
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum